To me, it’s again all about trust.
Bitwarden is still open source, but some people after this topic, won’t be using them anymore and understandably.
Nothing to my knowledge prevents Proton form undoing what they did with their structure kind of like what Bitwarden is changing their core values.
There’s several red or at least yellow flags and these four topics cover most of them:
What should…
github.com/privacyguides/privacyguides.org
main ← any1here:main
opened 03:41PM - 18 May 26 UTC
any1here
+0
-102
List of changes proposed in this PR: - Remove cromite due to lack of updates … Relevant discussions: https://discuss.privacyguides.net/t/remove-cromite/37896…
any1:
You can’t keep recommending a browser with over a month’s worth of security fixes missing.
Sadly, this is par for the course. Ever since PG messed up the Skiff recommendation, they have been unapologetically slow about tool suggestions / site development.
Remove ProtonVPN
we are not providing you with an SLA
Not sure how you want me to respond to that but I will say I am consistent on this issue. All offending reccomendations should be removed in all catagories.
Remove ProtonVPN
Any tool in any category that does not meet the minimum criteria should be removed, period. If PG is not going to enforce its own criteria, then there is no point in having them
Maybe this? Remove ProtonVPN @Nostromo
jonah:
The question is whether this “treatment” is delisting them, or if it is warning people about this error.
I think I am bit of a hard liner in this respect. I think, without extenuating circumstances (such as the kill switch issue which I think has some more reasonable nuance), if a tool does not meet the criteria, it should be removed. With that said, to me its clear Proton should…
jonah:
think the crux of the issue is that
includeAllNetworkssimply does not appear to cover the case where you disconnect from the VPN in order to connect to a different server , when it probably should. This is what most people would consider normal kill switch behavior
Gotcha. Without the includeAllNetworks flag, any 3p app can bypass the VPN on iOS / macOS at will. With that…
jonah:
think the crux of the issue is that
includeAllNetworkssimply does not appear to cover the case where you disconnect from the VPN in order to connect to a different server , when it probably should. This is what most people would consider normal kill switch behavior
Gotcha. Without the includeAllNetworks flag, any 3p app can bypass the VPN on iOS / macOS at will. With that…
Remove ProtonVPN
we are not providing you with an SLA that demands we submit PRs within 24 hours
What an odd strawman.
To be clear, my issues are not so much with the time it took as the attitude of staff toward it. Like…
Ignoring requests for an updated for weeks
Remove ProtonVPN
is @jonah or @staff going to respond to any of these VPN posts that came out during the holidays? It…